7.1 Spool's Usability Study

Although both pages shown are later versions of the ones tested, Edmund's site, which is almost all text, was found to be more usable than graphically dominant sites such as Disney.

Jarred M. Spool selected users who were familiar with a web browser, sat them down in front of a site, and watched them try to answer four types of questions: simple fact, comparison of facts, judgement, and comparison of judgement. Users had to hunt through the site to find the answer, even if they already knew it. Spool wanted to see how users searched for information in order to learn what factors of the site helped or hindered them.

Spool found that searching for information on the web is an intensely frustrating experience. Throughout his study he was amazed by the time and effort it took users to answer simple questions. Repeatedly users gave up without ever finding what they were looking for.